[Zope-CMF] One or two products?

[Chris Withers]

Yuppie wrote:
> First I'll propose some definitions:
> 
> CMFCore:
> - package (= Zope Product) of basic CMF modules
> - required by all other CMF packages

Yep.

> CMFDefault:
> - optional package
> - example implementation of CMF
> - the Dogbowl

Yes.

> - starting point for small projects and newbies

Nah, Plone seems much more common nowadays...

> CMF*:
> - optional package
> - implements special features or a complete cms
> - some of these packages may depend on others

Yep, although I really would like to see as few of these as possible, to keep 
the installation burden to a minimum.

> I think CMF should be distributed as a set of Zope Products:
> - CMFCore

I think this should be labelled "The CMF"

> - CMFDefault

I'd prefer this to be called "CMFDemo"

> - other CMF packages maintained by ZC
> (That's just like it is. And yes, I'd also like to have DCWorkflow as 
> part of this distribution.)

I think DCWorkflow belongs in CMFCore.

> But on the other hand, trying to use my definitions there is not much 
> left for CMFDefault. 

As it should be :-)

This is a list of CMFDefault imports:
> 
<snip>

As far as I could see, all of those should have been in CMFCore.

cheers,

Chris